Citizen's Bond Planning Committee
The Carrollton-Farmers Branch ISD Board of Trustees is committed to the district’s mission: to empower scholars to acquire life-long knowledge, skills, and values that prepare them to compete in the
world marketplace while contributing to their community.
The Board of Trustees also has been proactively planning for the district’s future and has been studying the district’s projected growth and other aging and evolving facility needs. This, in conjunction with the district’s belief in creating a collaborative culture in which all stakeholders may be a part of discussions regarding the district’s future, led the district to organize the Citizens Bond Planning Committee (CBPC). A committee is an invaluable group of community members formed to study the facility needs of the school district and ultimately present a recommendation to the CFBISD Board of Trustees for consideration.
Obtaining different perspectives from the entire community is very important to the process, and approximately 60 citizens from a variety of geographic areas and backgrounds make up the CBPC. Members of the committee will study a district-wide facilities assessment, enrollment projections, financial data, results of a community-wide survey, and more in order to make the best recommendation.
On January 24 members from the Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee presented a report highlighting their work during the past six months. The committee was charged with accessing and prioritizing the district’s current and long-term facility needs and reporting their findings to the Board of Trustees with recommendations on how to proceed with a long-range facilities plan. A report of these findings and the full presentation is now available to view. View Report
Calendar
Number of Members:
60 Citizens
Who:
Cross-Section Community
-
Parents
-
Senior Citizens
-
Community Leaders
-
Staff & Students
Nominations:
-
1 nomination per Board Member
-
Online form open to community member nominations
Charge:
Represent entire community in the facility-planning process by assessing and prioritizing current and long-term facility needs.
Deliverable:
Report findings to CFBISD Board of Trustees that will include a recommendation on how to proceed with the long-range facilities plan.
Timeline:
August 2022 to January 2023 with recommendation in January
Public Participation
The Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee process is designed to be open and transparent. All committee meetings will be open to the public. Non-committee members in attendance are invited to sit in the designated section for visitors and to listen, but not verbally participate. The non-committee members are encouraged to submit their questions and/or comments in writing on note cards that will be available at each meeting. Those questions and comments will be shared with the committee members and CFBISD administration. Answers will be communicated via email to guests who provide an email address on the note card.
Committee Members
The Carrollton-Farmers Branch ISD Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee includes a cross-section of our community, including parents and non-parents, young adults and senior citizens as well as district staff, business owners and community leaders.
We appreciate everyone who expressed an interest in serving on the committee and thank the following 60 individuals who make up the 2022-2023 Bond Planning Committee. Their time and input are very much appreciated.
- Abousaid, Isam
- Adams, Tamika
- Ahmed, Ikhlas
- Alan, Dani
- Allen, James
- Azhari, Marwan
- Bauer, Jennifer
- Carlin, Catherine
- Castaneda, Liz
- Chandran, Elias Sundar Raj
- Cody, William
- Drake, Cydnei
- Eatman, Josie
- Eisenmann, Mary
- Ellis, Nikki
- Etheridge, Diane
- Finney, Ruby
- Franco Jr, Noe
- Fuller, Jeff
- Hakimi, Shaima
- Halencak, Lee
- Harrington, Rori
- Hester, Matthew
- Hithersay, Anna
- Holmes, Elisabeth J (Liz)
- Kelly, Kane
- Khawla, Nabil
- Martini, Beth
- Mbah, Frank
- McIntosh, Erin
- Messer, Billy Bob
- Miller, Shannon
- Mills, Nehemiah
- Nunez, DeAnna
- Perez, Anita
- Porter, Jo Lyne
- Powell, Krisha
- Reyes, Edit
- Rinks, Joey
- Rivas, Jamie
- Root, Ruth
- Rude, Karl
- Salomon, Hector
- Sanders, Jason
- Sawicki, Mark
- Schackmann, Dr. Ruth
- Shattuck, Rob
- Smith, Brandy
- Smith, Herta
- Spindler, Laurie
- Stovall, Carrie
- Valentine, Kristina
- Vyakaranam, Lakshmana
- Walden, Ainsley
- Watson, Meredith
- Wells, Lisa
- Whitfield, Sarah
- Wright, Kaci
Frequently Asked Questions
- What is the Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee?
- Why did CFBISD form the Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee?
- Who’s on the committee?
- How were citizens selected to serve on the Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee?
- What documents and data is the committee reviewing to determine the needs of the school district?
- If I’m not on the committee, how do I learn more about what’s being discussed?
- Why is CFBISD considering a bond?
What is the Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee?
A group of community members who have come together to evaluate the district’s facilities in order to provide facility and equipment recommendations to the Carrollton-Farmers Branch ISD Board of Trustees. The committee will evaluate aging and evolving building needs, programmatic needs, as well as projected enrollment.
Why did CFBISD form the Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee?
The district believes in creating a collaborative culture in which all stakeholders may be a part of discussions regarding the district’s future. The district wants input in evaluating its facility needs and by forming a Committee it allows the district to hear from and incorporate many different perspectives from people in the CFBISD community. Committee participants reflect larger community values, needs, and desires.
Who’s on the committee?
The Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee represents a diverse demographic makeup of CFBISD residents, including parents, non-parents, grandparents, local civic and business leaders, as well as school and district staff. These committee members work alongside one another to prioritize and build a recommendation to the Board of Trustees that best represents the values and perceptions of the entire community.
How were citizens selected to serve on the Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee?
CFBISD sought nominations through an online form made available through the district’s website and that was shared through regular CFBISD communication channels. Anyone from the community was able to self nominate and/or nominate a friend, neighbor or family member. In addition, each CFBISD school board member was asked to nominate one individual to serve on the committee.
What documents and data is the committee reviewing to determine the needs of the school district?
Committee members are studying current building conditions and functionality, enrollment projections, financial data, and results of a community survey in order to form their recommendation. As additional relevant information and data is requested or becomes available, it will be shared with the committee members.
If I’m not on the committee, how do I learn more about what’s being discussed?
The Citizen’s Bond Planning Committee process is designed to be open and transparent. Meeting notes, presentations and agendas will be posted for each meeting, and all committee meetings will be open to the public. Non-committee members in attendance are invited to sit in the designated section for visitors and to listen, but not verbally participate. The non-committee members are encouraged to submit their questions and/or comments in writing on note cards that will be available at each meeting. Those questions and comments will be shared with the committee members and CFBISD administration. Answers will be communicated via email to guests who provide an email address on the note card.
Why is CFBISD considering a bond?
CFBISD’s motto is HIGH EXPECTATIONS FOR ALL, and that includes ourselves and the way we plan for and manage the district. Our vision is to be an exceptional learning community where all graduates impact and excel in a complex, interconnected, and ever-changing world. In order to realize our vision, we must plan for the future, maintain our facilities, and ensure we have funding needed to provide modern learning spaces and experiences for our students. The students of CFBISD are fortunate that the voters of our community share this passion for quality schools by passing our past bond referendums (including the most recent in 2018) to provide the tools and facilities our students and teachers need to succeed. As our facilities continue to age, we will continue to update our master facility plan to ensure our spaces meet current requirements and expectations of the communities we serve. We appreciate the ongoing support of the CFBISD community and remain committed to making sure bond funds are spent wisely and efficiently.
Meeting Summaries
Meeting #1
Meeting #1 Summary - August 25, 2022
Nancy Watten Technology and Event Center
Irving, Texas
6pm-8pm
Attendees:
- 51 Committee Members
- 15 District Leaders
- 1 School Board Trustee
Presenters:
- Dr. John E. Chapman, III
- Lesley Weaver, Huckabee & Associates
- Malcom Mulroney, Chief Operations Officer
- Larry Guerra, Chief Financial Officer
- Dr. Lance Hamline, Assistant Superintendent
- Leon Sulak, Principal, Dan F. Long Middle School
Meeting Agenda
- Welcome & Introductions
- Committee Charge & Process
- Define Consensus
- CFBISD: A District of Excellence
- Overview & Accolades
- School Finance 101
- Vision for Innovation & Instruction
- Bond History / Promises Made, Promises Kept
- 22 to 22 Committee Report
- Notes & Reflection
Action Item
The committee defined consensus as 75% consent, meaning 75% can support the recommendation.
Q & A
- How many years have we had an A+ rating for finance?
- How do we sell to the community (voters) that the tax rate is low compared to others when house values going up are making taxes increase dramatically?
- Is there any concern that the City of Carrollton is having its own bond election this November?
- Need to educate the voting public on CFBISD programs and future upgrades.
- Love all the PLC areas for teachers.
- Great presentations!
- I appreciate all the ways to help students with certifications. Could you also comment on college bound prep like AP classes, on-ramps, or dual credit classes?
- Are you proposing a $314 million budget for this bond? Why not more while interest rates are still very low?
- What is the projected student enrollment moving forward? How far in the future have you projected?
- A number of links and reports were referenced during the presentations, such as the bond website and Vision 2030 report card on strategic priorities. Can these be sent to committee members?
- Federal money for COVID? Did we get any? What was it used for?
- Interested to know more about technology infrastructure for the future job growth.
- Great presentations!
- CTE > Are all HS going to have multiple CTE options? Or do you choose HS based on
- What is the attrition rate of teachers or department staff compared to other ISDs?
- My neighbors asked me to check on the progress of current projects. I’m thrilled to take home the link to Malcolm’s document.
- The need for new furniture. As a student with a disability, sitting in a blue chair attached to a desk every day for 8 hours is not ideal.
- I really enjoyed hearing about CTE, but would have liked hearing something on college preparation.
- Do we need any new schools due to population growth?
How many years have we had an A+ rating for finance?
How do we sell to the community (voters) that the tax rate is low compared to others when house values going up are making taxes increase dramatically?
We share the information as often as we can; we’ll make that an emphasis during our informational campaign if the Board chooses to call a bond election; and we ask citizens like you to help share information with your friends, family and neighbors. If you know of any community groups (neighborhood associations, civic organizations, etc.) that would like to schedule time for us to speak, we would be honored to do so!
Is there any concern that the City of Carrollton is having its own bond election this November?
Need to educate the voting public on CFBISD programs and future upgrades.
If/when the Board of Trustees votes to call an election, we will execute a comprehensive communications plan to educate voters on what’s proposed. Keep in mind that during an election, CFBISD employees must adhere to the Election Code which does not allow for anything that can be considered advocacy or political advertising. While we can’t “sell” it, we will share facts about the proposal.
Love all the PLC areas for teachers.
Great presentations!
I appreciate all the ways to help students with certifications. Could you also comment on college bound prep like AP classes, on-ramps, or dual credit classes?
We celebrate excellent academic choice and programming in CFBISD. Advanced Placement, OnRamps and Dual Credit classes are offered in CFBISD facilities or at our partner college campuses. Unlike CTE classes, these courses work well in traditional classrooms. Please take a look at our Middle and High School Planning Guides. The information you requested begins on page 25 of the high school guide.
Are you proposing a $314 million budget for this bond? Why not more while interest rates are still very low?
At this point, there is not a set budget for our next bond. That will be determined in part by lifecycle needs we have, innovative changes this committee would like to recommend, and what the Board of Trustees chooses to call. It is likely that it would be higher than $314 million due to the number of projects we’re considering and the cost of inflation, etc. The $314 million talked about at the meeting was for the upcoming 2022-2023 operating (M&O) budget for the District. It is completely separate from any Bond (I&S) dollars, and has no bearing on what the proposed Bond will be at the May election.
What is the projected student enrollment moving forward? How far in the future have you projected?
A number of links and reports were referenced during the presentations, such as the bond website and Vision 2030 report card on strategic priorities. Can these be sent to committee members?
Federal money for COVID? Did we get any? What was it used for?
Interested to know more about technology infrastructure for the future job growth.
CTE works with industry partners, such as Cisco and AT&T, to offer industry standard curriculum and the necessary infrastructure for a variety of technology courses in both middle and high school. These courses include technology applications, cybersecurity, web development, IT support and services, networking and much more.
Great presentations!
CTE > Are all HS going to have multiple CTE options? Or do you choose HS based on
Each high school hosts at least three of the overarching Texas Education Agency approved CTE Programs of Study, each with multiple pathways, or majors. Students are able to select their high school campus by program and transportation to their home campus of choice is offered to students daily. interest?
Each high school hosts at least three of the overarching Texas Education Agency approved CTE Programs of Study, each with multiple pathways, or majors. Students are able to select their high school campus by program and transportation to their home campus of choice is offered to students daily.
What is the attrition rate of teachers or department staff compared to other ISDs?
For this past Spring, 83% of our teachers remained with CFBISD. However, if we also look at the reasons teachers departed, there are mitigating factors which increase our rate of retention. In our annual exit survey of departing staff, 79% reported their departure was because of a move out of this area. As we well know, these are unprecedented times and economic factors drive many employment decisions, not only in CFBISD. In removing the 79% from the number, we can report that our adjusted retention rate is 96.4%. At this juncture, the data on other ISD’s lags one year behind and would not be an accurate comparison.
My neighbors asked me to check on the progress of current projects. I’m thrilled to take home the link to Malcolm’s document.
The need for new furniture. As a student with a disability, sitting in a blue chair attached to a desk every day for 8 hours is not ideal.
I really enjoyed hearing about CTE, but would have liked hearing something on college preparation.
Do we need any new schools due to population growth?
Meeting #2
Meeting #2 Summary - September 8, 2022
R. L. Turner High School
Carrollton, Texas
6pm-8pm
Attendees:
- 53 Committee Members
- 15 Cabinet Members
- 1 School Board Trustee
Presenters:
- Lesley Weaver, Huckabee & Associates
- Malcom Mulroney, Chief Operations Officer
- Mario De La Rosa, Executive Director of Safety and Security
- Jo Gillen, Chief of SEL and Postsecondary Readiness
Meeting Agenda
-
Meeting #1 Recap
-
Capital Improvements & Lifecycle Replacement Needs at HS Level
-
Campus Tour
-
Safety & Security
-
Career & Technical Education (CTE)
-
Notes & Reflection
Q & A
- Outside of CTE, what is the district doing to provide basic home skills - cooking, cleaning, budgeting, etc.? “Life skills”
- Are there discussions on offering HVAC, Electricians, Plumbers, Heavy Equipment Operators? HVAC - stated it is at Newman Smith. Please work on CTE descriptions. No clue based on the description this was offered. CTE handout is very poor.
- The updates to safety and security discussed, is this everything or just a small piece of a bigger pie? To get everything you need & want, what is the rough cost?
- Are the windows bulletproof? Even the small windows on classroom doors?
- Safety & Security -- How do we ensure the investment in technology for safety will last? We won’t need to update or get new in 1-2 years?
- Why are SROs only assigned to secondary campuses? Why not elementary?
- With the security systems - How often are they tested to make sure staff follow them? What happens with violations?
- Is every camera in each school working? How often are they checked or updated?
- What safety and security are students offered from teachers that are bullies? What reporting methods?
- Does CFB do background “Raptor” checks each year for ALL employees and construction employees? If no, why not? Parents have to do new ones every year.
- I am assuming all these newer classrooms are equipped to meet disability compliance? Exm: wheelchair
- Is transportation provided to students who choose a HS outside of their feeder pattern?
- Why does the Child Development Academy and Marie Huie Special Education Center not show up on map? Two very important parts of CFBISD.
- How does the district recruit industry partners?
- Moderator needs to improve instruction -- not clear.
- Please provide the link to the most recent update on the Vivian Field renovations. Current videos on the CFBISD appear to be older than the one we watched in Meeting #1.
- I see CTE spaces achieved A+. How are the academies coming along?
- What % of CFBISD students participate in a CTE program?
- What % of Carrollton residents have a child in CFBISD schools?
- Does the marching band still practice in the parking lot/on concrete? If so, are there plans to create their own practice (grassy/turf) space? Former marching band member here. :)
Outside of CTE, what is the district doing to provide basic home skills - cooking, cleaning, budgeting, etc.? “Life skills”
Are there discussions on offering HVAC, Electricians, Plumbers, Heavy Equipment Operators? HVAC - stated it is at Newman Smith. Please work on CTE descriptions. No clue based on the description this was offered. CTE handout is very poor.
HVAC, Construction Management & Inspection, Electrical, Carpentry, Architectural Design, and Interior Design pathways are all offered under the Architecture & Construction program of study at Newman Smith High School. Culinary Arts is offered under the Hospitality & Tourism program of study at Ranchview High School. For more information regarding the programs of study offered in CFBISD, and their associated pathways, please visit cfbisd.edu/CTE.
The updates to safety and security discussed, is this everything or just a small piece of a bigger pie? To get everything you need & want, what is the rough cost?
Information presented on September 8 included the items we’re currently considering for safety & security updates. We plan to present costs for all project considerations (safety & security plus other potential bond projects) during Meeting #6 on November 17.
To clarify the process for considering bond projects and developing project budgets:
Step 1: Ensure that committee members have an opportunity to hear about all potential projects and provide initial feedback (through the discussions, on the handouts, etc.).
Step 2: District staff and consultants will develop costs for the projects that seem of interest to the committee and for projects that are an absolute need (accessibility, failing systems, etc.).
Step 3: Project budgets and potential costs will be shared with the committee, and committee members will be asked to prioritize projects based on need, costs, etc.
Are the windows bulletproof? Even the small windows on classroom doors?
Safety & Security -- How do we ensure the investment in technology for safety will last? We won’t need to update or get new in 1-2 years?
Why are SROs only assigned to secondary campuses? Why not elementary?
Our local police department partners were consulted regarding the possibility of having an SRO at every elementary school. The PDs are currently experiencing a shortage of officers and cannot fill their vacant positions. Therefore, there are not SROs available. In order to enhance security for the elementary campuses it was decided CFBISD would hire a security officer for each elementary campus. CFBISD is currently recruiting, hiring, and the security officers.
With the security systems - How often are they tested to make sure staff follow them? What happens with violations?
Is every camera in each school working? How often are they checked or updated?
What safety and security are students offered from teachers that are bullies? What reporting methods?
Does CFB do background “Raptor” checks each year for ALL employees and construction employees? If no, why not? Parents have to do new ones every year.
CFBISD uses Raptor for visitor checks on each campus. Human Resources conducts an extensive background check at the time of employment. The district is notified when an alarm is triggered due to an arrest or criminal wrongdoing.
CFBISD requires all contractors to conduct background checks on their employees and construction staff. CFBISD also requires construction staff to wear a district identification badge while working on CFB properties.
I am assuming all these newer classrooms are equipped to meet disability compliance? Exm: wheelchair
Is transportation provided to students who choose a HS outside of their feeder pattern?
Why does the Child Development Academy and Marie Huie Special Education Center not show up on map? Two very important parts of CFBISD.
How does the district recruit industry partners?
CFBISD’s CTE department recruits industry partners in a variety of ways. This includes, but is not limited to, engaging in local chamber of commerce meetings, attending workforce solutions and rotary events, networking at industry fairs and conferences, sending emails and letters to partners of interest, visiting local businesses, and good old fashioned word of mouth.
Moderator needs to improve instruction -- not clear.
Please provide the link to the most recent update on the Vivian Field renovations. Current videos on the CFBISD appear to be older than the one we watched in Meeting #1.
I see CTE spaces achieved A+. How are the academies coming along?
CFBISD’s academies are thriving under the realignment of CTE programs of study. Enrollment is back up following the pandemic and we have recently added new academies, such as four P-TECHs (Texas Education Agency designated Pathways in Technology Early College High School) and one NAF Academy. Academies are added to campuses to fit the interests of our students and the needs of our industry partners, along with current labor market data.
What % of CFBISD students participate in a CTE program?
What % of Carrollton residents have a child in CFBISD schools?
Does the marching band still practice in the parking lot/on concrete? If so, are there plans to create their own practice (grassy/turf) space? Former marching band member here. :)
Meeting #3
Meeting #3 Summary - September 22, 2022
Vivian Field Middle School
Farmers Branch, Texas
6pm-8:30pm
Attendees:
- 43 Committee Members
- 15 Cabinet Members
Presenters:
- Lesley Weaver, Huckabee & Associates
- Dr. Mark Rohwer, Director of Fine Arts
- Renee Putter, Athletics Director
- Malcom Mulroney, Chief Operations Officer
Meeting Agenda
-
Committee Progress and Meeting #2 Recap
-
Ballot Requirements for Separate Propositions
-
Fine Arts
-
Athletics
-
Capital Improvements & Lifecycle Replacement Needs at MS Level
-
Tour
-
Notes & Reflection
Q & A
- Wasn’t the pool just closed for reno for a length of time -- over spring/summer 2022?
- How many people use the Stadium on an annual basis?
- How much revenue does Stadium generate?
- Are the videos only used for the purpose of the Bond Prep Committee or where else used? How much is spent? Example - Fine Arts Program Overview
- With the example of Polk track “falling” apart. Was this a design flaw? Just wear & tear? How do we make this better in the future?
- The information and tour of middle school needs focused heavily on classroom spaces, yet there was no discussion of classroom spaces at the high school level. Why?
- The fine arts discussion repeatedly mentions a lack of equity between schools in the district. Has the district reviewed the decisions that created these issues so they are not repeated?
- Why did the district partially renovate campuses? Poor planning?
- Great to renovate athletics and fine arts but what about science labs? Are they “state of the art”? Or is there a plan to upgrade them?
- Can we stick better to closing time?
- It was mentioned that both the Bush and Field choir rooms are renovated, but Bush is still smaller. Why wasn’t this resolved when it was renovated?
Wasn’t the pool just closed for reno for a length of time -- over spring/summer 2022?
The Natatorium was closed to install a new pump and motor system for the circulation of the water in the pool. The deck had some tiles that needed replacing as well as a new coat of paint for the walls. Some rebar was exposed in the sides of the pool and the pool had to be drained to fix a few wall spots. Lastly, the bulkhead and starting blocks were rusted and did not meet the City of Carrollton codes for pools and had to be replaced. This caused the pool to be down from the end of May until August when school started. This was paid for with 2018 bond funds.
How many people use the Stadium on an annual basis?
Varsity Football Games:
Approximately 100 members on both teams, 100 members of each band, 30 members of each dance team, 15 members of each cheer squad, Approximately 60 game/concession/security staff. Average 2,500 patrons for a total of 3,550 per varsity game. For approximately 22 varsity football games that is 77,000.
We also host 23 sub-varsity and middle school football games, including approximately 50 members on both teams, 20 game workers and 500 patrons for a total of 620 per game. Totaling approximately 14,260.
We also host approximately 75 varsity, sub-varsity, and middle school soccer games, 4 middle school and 4 high school track meets, Elementary Field Days, Kacey’s Run, Special Olympics, and the 5A UIL Regional Soccer Tournament.
Approximately 2500 attendees for each high school soccer game, 900 for each middle school track meet, 1600 attendees per day of the elementary Field Days (3 days), 122,000 for each High School track meet, 1,200 attendees for Kacey’s Run and Special Olympics, 5,000 for the UIL Regional Soccer tournament.
Sport/Activity |
Number of Attendees |
Soccer |
15,000 |
Middle School Track |
3.600 |
High School Track |
8,000 |
Elementary Field Days |
4,800 |
Special Events |
2.400 |
UIL Regional Soccer |
5,000 |
Fall (football) |
91,260 |
Winter/Spring (non football) |
38,800 |
Total Patrons |
139,060 |
How much revenue does Stadium generate?
Are the videos only used for the purpose of the Bond Prep Committee or where else used? How much is spent? Example - Fine Arts Program Overview
-
The fine arts and athletic videos were produced in 2017/18
-
The CTE video was developed by Turner AMAT (Academy of Media Arts & Technology) students
-
Turner and Field videos were part of the 2018 Bond Project and used as part of the Promises Made, Promises Kept report.
The Fine Arts video shared at the Citizens’ Bond Committee meeting #3 was produced in the 2017-2018 school year before the 2018 bond election. The video is used to market to potential fine arts students (and their parents) as well as on the website. Additionally, the video is shown to new faculty and staff at New Teacher Training each year. It was produced by Modern Reel, a CFB vendor who has done similar video work for the district over the years; the cost was $2,800. We feel like the video shows in a short time why students who are involved in the arts are so passionate about it. This video/information is important to have available to the community, including parents who might be trying to decide if CFBISD is a good choice for their children. Branding is an important part of advocating for our programs, and on behalf of our students.
With the example of Polk track “falling” apart. Was this a design flaw? Just wear & tear? How do we make this better in the future?
The information and tour of middle school needs focused heavily on classroom spaces, yet there was no discussion of classroom spaces at the high school level. Why?
At the high schools, we only did strategic improvements focused in the areas outlined in the 2018 Bond requirements. At Field and Perry we were able to work through the whole campus in the “grand vision” this type of work is being proposed in the 2023 Bond.
We did discuss high school classroom spaces in the Fine Arts presentation – the problems with classroom size for choirs, theatre storage, and secondary “breakout” rooms for band and orchestra – but, as the newest classroom spaces in the district for the Fine Arts are middle school ones, and not high school ones, it was easier to compare new middle school spaces to other middle school ones.
The fine arts discussion repeatedly mentions a lack of equity between schools in the district. Has the district reviewed the decisions that created these issues so they are not repeated?
We did discuss high school classroom spaces in the Fine Arts presentation – the problems with classroom size for choirs, theatre storage, and secondary “breakout” rooms for band and orchestra – but, as the newest classroom spaces in the district for the Fine Arts are middle school ones, and not high school ones, it was easier to compare new middle school spaces to other middle school ones.
There is no perfect solution because of the constantly changing programs and requirements. However, we have been mapping the different sizes and establishing District Standards, this allows us to plan projects that support student equity.
Why did the district partially renovate campuses? Poor planning?
Great to renovate athletics and fine arts but what about science labs? Are they “state of the art”? Or is there a plan to upgrade them?
Can we stick better to closing time?
It was mentioned that both the Bush and Field choir rooms are renovated, but Bush is still smaller. Why wasn’t this resolved when it was renovated?
Meeting #4
Meeting #4 Summary - October 13, 2022
Sheffield Elementary (new building)
Carrollton, Texas
6pm-8:30pm
Attendees:
- 42 Committee Members
- 15 District Leaders
Presenters:
- Lesley Weaver, Huckabee & Associates
- Craig Drone, LPA Design Studios
- Tracy Smith, Assistant Superintendent of Teaching and Learning
Meeting Agenda
-
Meeting 3 Recap
-
Capital Improvements & Lifecycle Replacement Needs at ES Level
-
Tour
-
Special Education
-
Notes & Reflection
Q & A
- How many meetings were elementary staff involved in (if any)?
- Which architect designed Sheffield?
- What is the final construction cost (as close as possible) of Sheffield?
- How many elementary teachers were involved with design-up of Sheffield?.
- Feedback from the new campus’s staff is crucial before the next design.
- Campuses got updated? Where is the equity for FBE, Carrollton and Central?
- The library space appears to be an oversized lobby. Was it intended to be a space where quietness is available? It doesn’t appear to be possible.
- Library location is not ideal. Too much traffic and distraction.
- How many elevators on the new campus?
- Is Sheffield the first school in the district to do this new pod design? If not, have you seen improved learning & experience with them?
- Is the district considering the functionality of the buildings as well? (ie Bush Middle School)
- What about Grimes and Bea Salazar? Why are they not included in the bond?
- Are any of the admin buildings going to be discussed? COA, Maria Huie, Central Admin, Bus Barn, Maintenance Facilities
- Do the new designs take into a back up plan if a COVID situation were to arise again? (all schools)
- What do we have left to be done from the last bond? Time Frame to finish.
- Are the number of elementary schools we have needed? Do we need more, less, etc.?
- Why are the 3 ES campuses with the greatest need still waiting for reno when so many newer ES ½?
- Bathroom privacy needs will be an issue, especially for the older children. Was this considered?
- Are parents aware of the new bathroom shared experience? What happens if there is push back?
How many meetings were elementary staff involved in (if any)?
Which architect designed Sheffield?
What is the final construction cost (as close as possible) of Sheffield?
How many elementary teachers were involved with design-up of Sheffield?.
Feedback from the new campus’s staff is crucial before the next design.
Campuses got updated? Where is the equity for FBE, Carrollton and Central?
The dollars allocated in 2018 for the three elementary schools with the greatest need would only scratch the surface to address the needs at these campuses. Through the process of developing educational guidelines and visioning for new Sheffield, the district leadership, faculties team and consultants recognized that these three schools need significant repair and possible replacement.
The library space appears to be an oversized lobby. Was it intended to be a space where quietness is available? It doesn’t appear to be possible.
Library location is not ideal. Too much traffic and distraction.
How many elevators on the new campus?
Is Sheffield the first school in the district to do this new pod design? If not, have you seen improved learning & experience with them?
At an elementary level, yes - in the district, no. The middle schools have successfully implemented pod designs as have the career tech programs at the HS. This is not entirely a new concept for elementary schools - as the research and educational design has shifted in the last decade to more collaborative settings.
Is the district considering the functionality of the buildings as well? (ie Bush Middle School)
What about Grimes and Bea Salazar? Why are they not included in the bond?
Are any of the admin buildings going to be discussed? COA, Maria Huie, Central Admin, Bus Barn, Maintenance Facilities
Do the new designs take into a back up plan if a COVID situation were to arise again? (all schools)
What do we have left to be done from the last bond? Time Frame to finish.
Are the number of elementary schools we have needed? Do we need more, less, etc.?
Why are the 3 ES campuses with the greatest need still waiting for reno when so many newer ES ½?
The dollars allocated in 2018 for the three elementary schools with the greatest need would only scratch the surface to address the needs at these campuses.
Through the process of developing educational guidelines and Visioning for new Sheffield, the district leadership, faculties team and consultants recognized that these three schools are in need of significant repair and possible replacement.
Bathroom privacy needs will be an issue, especially for the older children. Was this considered?
Are parents aware of the new bathroom shared experience? What happens if there is push back?
Meeting #5
Meeting #5 Summary - October 27, 2022
Carrollton Elementary
Carrollton, Texas
6pm-8pm
Attendees:
- 36 Committee Members
- 15 District Leaders
- 1 School Board Trustee
Presenters:
-
Lesley Weaver, Huckabee & Associates
-
Malcolm Mulroney, Chief Operations Officer
-
Sandy Meyer, Director of Early Childhood Education
-
Scott Monroe, Chief Technology Officer Bill Neyland, Robert Welsh, Director of Technology
-
Brent Alexander, Residential Strategies (Demographer’s Report)
Meeting Agenda
-
Early Childhood Education
-
Technology & Fiber
-
Demographer’s Report
-
Prioritization Factors
Q & A
- What is the percentage of students that actually stay in CFBISD K-12th?
- Demographics = What were the changes for Avg HH size 2.4, Med. age 34.9, HH income $77K? What was it before?
- Pre-K = noted that 80% of Pre-K do not have a student bathroom. What is the # of general elementary classrooms that have a student bathroom?
- Pre-K = does Pre-K need dedicated outdoor space or can this be more general or built for all students or at least younger students?
- Pre-K = is there any type of program where we can donate furniture? Kids kitchen? Kids store?
- Is CDA being considered for Early Childhood updates?
- Who provides internet services for the district? Frontier? Spectrum? Different service?
- Is our fiber in a duct bank or direct bury?
- Who owns the row our cable is in?
- What type of utility agreements are in place? Is it our responsibility to relocate lines if the roadway is expanded
What is the percentage of students that actually stay in CFBISD K-12th?
The demographer does not have the data on the number of students that stay through, K-12. This is a difficult question to answer for the demographer without all the data. We would have to do a KG/12 grade comparison using student ID’s. For example, how many KG student ID’s enrolled in 2008/09 are still present in 2022/23.
Demographics = What were the changes for Avg HH size 2.4, Med. age 34.9, HH income $77K? What was it before?
Pre-K = noted that 80% of Pre-K do not have a student bathroom. What is the # of general elementary classrooms that have a student bathroom?
Pre-K = does Pre-K need dedicated outdoor space or can this be more general or built for all students or at least younger students?
Pre-K = is there any type of program where we can donate furniture? Kids kitchen? Kids store?
Is CDA being considered for Early Childhood updates?
Who provides internet services for the district? Frontier? Spectrum? Different service?
Is our fiber in a duct bank or direct bury?
Who owns the row our cable is in?
What type of utility agreements are in place? Is it our responsibility to relocate lines if the roadway is expanded
Meeting #6
Meeting #6 Summary - November 17, 2022
Blalack Middle School
Carrollton, Texas
6pm-8pm
Attendees:
- 37 Committee Members
- 15 District Leaders
- 1 School Board Trustee
Presenters:
-
Arena Blake, Huckabee & Associates
-
Larry Guerra, Chief Financial Officer
-
Laura Alexander & Robert Spears, Hilltop Securities
-
Malcolm Mulroney, Chief Operations Officer & Lelia Goehring, Director Planning and Facilities
-
Core Construction, Joeris General Contractors, Northstar Builders Group
Meeting Agenda
- Meeting 5 Recap + Responses from Google Form
- Bonding Capacity & Tax Impact Scenarios
- Design Process Overview
- Construction Panel Discussion
- Review All Potential Projects Presented + Options
- Project Budgets
- Prioritization Activity
Q & A
Is there an opportunity for outdoor water stations on the school fields? There’s nowhere to fill water bottles when outdoors, athletic time, games, etc.
We provide water cows, which is a portable water station at all outdoor practices/games on the fields for middle school and high school athletes. There are drinking fountains near the restrooms/concession stands at most of the campus game fields.
For patrons who wish to fill their own water bottles when outside food or drink is not allowed, some campus fields have a drinking fountain near the concession stands. Some of the newly created fields do not.
We always have water for the athletes while indoor and outdoors at practice and games.
Meeting #7
Meeting #7 Summary - December 8, 2022
Nancy Watten Technology and Event Center
Irving, Texas
6pm-8pm
Attendees:
- 30 Committee Members
- 15 District Leaders
- 1 School Board Trustee
Presenters:
-
Lesley Weaver, Huckabee & Associates
-
Matt Gamble, Baselice & Associates
-
Malcolm Mulroney, Chief Operations Officer & Lelia Goehring, Director Planning and Facilities
Meeting Agenda
-
Meeting 6 Recap
-
Review Elementary Prioritization Feedback
-
Prioritization Activity
-
Middle School Projects
-
High School Projects
-
District Facility Projects
-
-
Community Survey Results
Meeting #8
Meeting #8 Summary - December 15, 2022
Nancy Watten Technology and Event Center
Irving, Texas
6pm-8pm
Attendees:
- 37 Committee Members
- 15 District Leaders
- 1 School Board Trustee
Presenters:
-
Lesley Weaver, Huckabee & Associates
-
Malcolm Mulroney, Chief Operations Officer & Lelia Goehring, Director Planning and Facilities
Meeting Agenda
-
Finance Update
-
Project Recap
-
Brief Recap on Elementary Prioritization Feedback from Meeting 6
-
Review Secondary Prioritization Feedback
-
Review Alternative Education Prioritization Feedback
-
-
Build-A-Bond
-
Reach Consensus & Finalize Recommendation
-
Next Steps & Election Information
Meeting #9
Meeting #9 Summary - January 5, 2023
Nancy Watten Technology and Event Center
Irving, Texas
6pm-8pm
Attendees:
- 32 Committee Members
- 15 District Leaders
- 1 School Board Trustee
Presenters:
-
Lesley Weaver, Huckabee & Associates
-
Malcolm Mulroney, Chief Operations Officer & Lelia Goehring, Director Planning and Facilities
Meeting Agenda
-
Recap Ballot Results from Meeting 8
-
Projects with Consensus
-
Projects that Need Additional Discussion
-
-
Group Build-A-Bond Activity
-
Voting on Projects that Need Additional Discussion or Had <50%
-
Reach Consensus & Finalize Recommendation
-
-
Next Steps & Election Information